Showing posts with label dealing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dealing. Show all posts

Saturday, May 21, 2016

Article 2: Going Forward


As of this post, we have looked at some of the basic concepts in the formation of a contract under Article 2 including: the Statute of Frauds under Section 2-201; the importance of the distinction between a merchant and non merchant under Article 2; battle of the forms under Section 2-207; parol evidence under Section 2-202; recovery of attorneys’ fees as consequential damages under Section 2-607(5)(a); right to adequate assurance of performance under Section 2-609, and the failure of presupposed conditions under Section 2-615.
All of this is supplemented with all of the posts on Article 1 starting with the Purposes and Policies of the UCC as stated in Section 1-102, and the mandate to the courts to ‘liberally construe and apply’ the Code to further these policies.  The policies stated in Article 1 create a macro framework through which to process all of the Uniform Commercial Code.  These blend with the policies of a particular Article in the interpretation process. Supplemental rules of law under Section 1-103(b) is another section which allows facts to be uniquely applied to the supplemental area of law which applies to the case.  For those of you seeking to learn Article 2, it would be helpful to review the earlier posts on Article 1, followed by the Article 2 posts.  The more thorough your knowledge of Article 1, the better your foundation for everything that follows.
As we go forward with Article 2, several things should be stated.  First—and this is my opinion—sales transactions are the least formalized transactions under the Uniform Commercial Code.  By that I mean it is less likely that there will be a finalized, integrated document which has been formally executed than in any of the other Articles.  Sales transactions often involve a phone call, some correspondence, a shipping document and conduct which recognizes the existence of the contract.  As a result, terms supplied by the Code have greater significance.
Second, the Article 2 expectation is that in the event of a dispute the parties will work it out through negotiation.  This is a reflection of how these matters are handled in reality, and is reflected in the general structure and content of Article 2. Hence, comment 4 to Section 2-607, which deals with a buyer’s duty to notify a seller of a breach with respect to accepted goods states:
The notification which saves the buyer’s rights under this Article need only be such as informs the seller that the transaction is claimed to involve a breach, and thus opens the way for normal settlement through negotiation.
The ‘looseness’ of Article 2 in this regard is to be contrasted with the specificity of other Articles. Under Article 9, for example, you are more likely to find a definitive answer to a problem than you would under Article 2.  Secured lenders want certainty when enforcement of a secured obligation must take place.  Thus, the policy of certainty is expressed in the text of Article 9 and the policy of ‘keep the deal alive’ is expressed in the structure and text of Article 2.
            Third, the definitions of ‘contract’ and ‘agreement’ as defined under Article 1 have particular significance under Article 2.  This follows from the lack of formality referred to above.  Thus, course of performance, course of dealing and usage of trade need to be carefully examined in each instance to see how a particular concept might impact the contract.  As noted in an earlier post, a particular transaction may not involve a ‘course of performance’ or ‘course of dealing’ since parties may be dealing with one and other for the first time, and the contract may not call for ‘repeated occasions for performance’ with objectionable behavior.  However, virtually all sales transactions occur within some trade or industry which has its own rules and protocols.  Absent limiting contract provisions, these rules and protocols become part of the contract. Trade journals are a potential source of incredibly valuable information.
             Part 3 of Article 2 deals with General Obligations of the Parties:  Among other things, Part 3 supplies certain terms that the parties may not have included in their written agreement or writings.  For example, in certain circumstances parties to a contract can conclude a binding deal without have explicitly agreed on a price; the Code will supply a place of delivery if none has been stated; and where action is required by no timeline stated, the Code requires that action be taken within a ‘reasonable time’.  This ties into a Section 2-204(3) discussed in an earlier post:
A contract does not fail for indefiniteness if the parties intended a contract and there is a reasonably certain basis for giving an appropriate remedy.
Section 2-301 states the obligations of the buyer and seller in very general terms:
The obligation of the seller is to transfer and deliver and that of the buyer is to accept       and pay in accordance with the contract.
 The comment to Section 2-301 explains this as follows:
In order to determine what is in ‘accordance with the contract’ under this Article usage of trade, course of dealing and performance, and the general background of circumstances must be given due consideration in conjunction with the lay meaning of the words used to define the scope of the conditions and duties.
 Section 2-301 thus forms the foundation for going forward in litigation; implicitly emphasizes the importance of drafting; and explicitly recognizes ‘usage of trade, course of dealing and performance’ as critical elements in determining the terms and interpretation of a contract.  These concepts, the drafting style of Article 2, and the overall purposes and policies of the Code should be incorporated in the process of analyzing Article 2 transactions.

Thursday, January 14, 2016

Parol Evidence and Article 2

 We have discussed the basic drafting of Article 2 insofar as it relates to the general formation of a contract, noting that the Code has removed many formal restrictions for contract formation which existed in pre Code law.  This is consistent with the overall drafting of Article 2 which reflects the reality of the business world.  Often, there is no finalized contract, but instead a series of writings followed by conduct which recognizes the existence of a contract.  If there is an acceptance in ‘confirmation of an offer’ the rules of Section 2-207 will apply.
In that situation, and even in situations where you have a finalized contract, parties may wish to introduce evidence which assist the court in interpreting the writings in a manner favorable to the proponent of the evidence.  In that situation, Section 2-202 comes into play.  That section reads as follows:
Terms with respect to which the confirmatory memoranda of the parties agree or which are otherwise set forth in a writing intended by the parties as a final expression of their agreement with respect to such terms as are included therein may not be contradicted by evidence of any prior agreement or of a contemporaneous oral agreement but may be explained or supplemented
(a) by course of dealing or usage of trade (Section 1-205) or by course of performance (Section 2-208); and
(b) by evidence of consistent additional terms unless the court finds the writing to have been intended also as a complete and exclusive statement of the terms of the agreement .
            Section 2-202 once again, underscores the importance of the individual elements of agreement in the ultimate interpretation of the meaning of the contract.  Thus, course of performance, course of dealing, and usage of trade not only create avenues whereby conduct and trade can supply terms of a contract, but also create an avenue by which evidence can be introduced to ‘explain or supplement’ the terms contained in any writings between the parties.  The manner in which this evidence is presented to the court is critical.  If the evidence of course of performance, course of dealing and trade usage is presented to ‘contradict’ the writing, it is not acceptable. If however, such evidence is introduced to ‘explain or supplement the writings’ the evidence is proper.  This is true regardless of whether or not the writings are intended as a ‘final expression’ of the parties’ agreement.
            Section 2-202 was discussed by the Arkansas Court of Appeals in L.F. Brands v Dillard’s 314 SW 3d 736, 2009 and, like most cases which have disc used Section 2-202, reached a decision that was consistent with the statute.  The case involved a breach of contract action brought by L.F. Brands against Dillard’s.  Brands was a supplier of Dillard’s with whom Dillard’s had a long standing relationship.  All transactions between the parties were governed by a document entitled ‘Dillard’s Inc. Purchase Order Terms, Conditions, and Instructions’.  In addition to the terms contained in the purchase orders, undisputed testimony from Brands and Dillard’s employees established that the parties would meet at the beginning of each fashion season to discuss profit margins.  Sales were monitored throughout the course of the season, and allowances would be processed at various times during the year to make adjustments to the margins.  At the end of the year, parties would determine if gross margins had been met.  If not, the parties would negotiate on further allowances to achieve an acceptable resolution.
            Among the provisions contained in the Purchase Order agreement was the following provision:
[L.F. Brands] acknowledges by acceptance and shipment against any Dillard Purchase Order that the terms, conditions and instructions stated herein, in the Purchase Order, [and in two other Dillard's documents] (collectively, the “Agreement”) shall bind [L .F. Brands] and shall constitute the entire agreement between Dillard and [L.F. Brands], which cannot be modified by either party except in a writing executed by both parties, or [another method]; provided, however, that this provision shall not apply to markdown allowance and other credits authorized by [L.F. Brands]․
L.F. Brands went out of business in December of 2003.  In February 2004, Dillard’s deducted markdown allowances and chargeback’s from its account balance.   These markdowns and chargebacks were the basis of Brands’ appeal. 
The trial court denied both parties’ motion for summary judgment determining that the entirety of the parties’ agreement must be determined by looking at both the written documents, as supplemented by the parties’ oral agreements.  The case was submitted to a jury with instructions with the definition of course of dealing, and that course of dealing evidence may be used to give particular meaning to and supplement the terms of the agreement.  The jury found for Dillard’s on the complaint, and further found for Dillard’s on its counterclaim in the amount of $1,265,938.98
            In discussing Brand’s argument that the merger clause in the Purchase Order superceded the prior oral agreements concerning merchandise allowances the Court stated:
This argument sweeps too broadly in this case for the sale of goods governed by Article 2 of the Uniform Commercial Code(UCC) which has a specific provision allowing parol evidence to be introduced even in situations involving fully integrated written agreements.  Under the UCC’s parol evidence rule, a writing intended to the parties’ final expression of their agreement may not be contradicted by evidence of any prior agreement or contemporaneous oral agreement, but it may be supplemented by evidence of the parties’ course of dealing or course of performance. [citing Section 2-202(a).]
The court went on to state:
In such instances, the evidence of a course of dealing that explains or supplements a contract is competent evidence of the parties’ intent and can become a part of a contract.
In affirming the trial court, the court of appeals also noted that, per comment one to Section 2-202, there is no requirement that the contract be ambiguous in order for such evidence to be introduced.
This case underscores a point that has been made repeatedly in previous posts—course of dealing and course of performance, if they exist, are always relevant.  If however, the parties choose to do so, they can include a provision in their contract which excludes evidence of course of dealing, course of performance or usage of trade.  If you are drafting a contract, it is a good practice to examine each of these concepts in the context of your situation, so that any desired adjustments can be made.



Thursday, December 17, 2015

Battle of the Forms: No Battle


The Reply Doctrine of Section 2-201(2) creates a logical introduction to Section 2-207—Battle of the Forms.  In fact, Section 2-207(1) uses language almost identical to Section 2-201(2) insofar as it speaks of a ‘written confirmation’ of acceptance.  Before turning to the text and meaning of Section 2-207, it should be noted that this section has been heavily litigated with differing interpretations as to its meaning.
            Section 2-207 provides an opportunity to demonstrate the connectivity between Code sections, and the intertwining of meaning.  The skilled advocate creates a logical sequence through all of that with a favorable outcome.  For example, standing alone you have fairly clear statutory text for Section 2-201(2).  ‘A writing in confirmation’ is very clear when stated like the example given in the last post.  Of course, in reality it is rarely done so cleanly.  Rather, the writing in confirmation may be a simple purchase order, with no specific confirmation language, and courts have so held.
            The Code sections which immediately come into play are Sections 1-201(b)(3),(12), the definitions of agreement and contract.  This in turn activates Section 1-303 and the elements of course of performance, course of dealing and usage of trade. There are also supplemental principles of law which may apply pursuant to Section 1-303(b). As facts are added to the substantive provisions of the statute, the Code sections come to life with new interpretations.  These various interpretations create a very dynamic and fertile ground for structuring arguments or drafting provisions in a manner most favorable to your client.
            As for Section 2-207, I believe that section can be understood by a careful reading of the text of the statute.  As I was taught ‘The answer is always in the Statute.’  At the outset, one must remember that Section 2-207 is predicated upon an offer having already been made by either the buyer or seller, for the section speaks in terms of a ‘definite and seasonable expression of acceptance or a written confirmation’.  There can be no acceptance or written confirmation unless an offer has been made. [Unless of course, someone is using Section 2-201(2) to solidify a deal that may or may not have existed.]
Section 2-207(1) states as follows:
(1) A definite and seasonable expression of acceptance or a written confirmation which is sent within a reasonable time operates as an acceptance even though it states terms additional to or different from those offered or agreed upon, unless acceptance is expressly made conditional on assent to the additional or different terms.
The rule of Section 2-207(1) is clear and straightforward.  It contemplates an acceptance or written confirmation of an offer, with the acceptance presenting additional terms to those offered.  The rule is that the acceptance is binding unless the acceptance is made conditional on the offeror’s assent to the additional terms.  In other words, it is a ‘take it or leave it’ acceptance.
            For example, Seller offers buyer 1,000 pairs of shoes for $18.00 per pair with no stated delivery terms.  Buyer sends the following response:
I accept your offer to buy 1,000 shoes at $18.00 per pair, delivery to be made in five separate lots of 200 units per lot.
Under Section 2-207(1), Buyer has accepted Seller’s offer.  Delivery in five lots is not a condition to Buyer’s acceptance, simply a statement or request.
If on the other hand, Buyer had demanded inclusion of his delivery term as a prerequisite to the acceptance, there would be no acceptance under Section 2-207(1).  In that scenario, Buyer’s proffered acceptance might read as follows:
I accept your offer to buy 1,000 shoes at $18.00 per pair.  However, I need delivery in five separate lots of 200 units per lot or I will not do the deal.
Buyer has made his ‘acceptance’ conditional upon Seller’s acquiescence to his delivery demand.  Hence, no acceptance.
            Section 2-207(2) explains what happens when additional terms are proposed but not made as a condition to the acceptance:
The additional terms are to be construed as proposals for addition to the contract. Between merchants such terms become part of the contract unless:
(a) the offer expressly limits acceptance to the terms of the offer;
(b) they materially alter it; or
(c) notification of objection to them has already been given or is given within a reasonable time after notice of them is received.
In the first part of the example given above, Buyer’s request for delivery in five lots would be treated as a ‘proposal’ for addition to the contract.  If both parties involved in the transaction are merchants, Buyer’s delivery proposal will become part of the contract unless one of the contingencies covered in Section 2-207(2) occurs.  For example, one question might become whether the proposed delivery terms ‘materially alter’ the original offer.  Trade custom would have particular relevance here.
            It is interesting to note that the first contingency stated in 2-207(2) goes back to the original offer which set things in motion.  If that offer is a ‘take it or leave it’ proposal, no additional terms will be incorporated into the contract.  If the additional terms ‘materially alter’ the offer, they will not be included.  And finally, if a notice of objection to the additional terms has been given within a reasonable time, the terms will not become part of the contract.       
            So, at this point we have two take it or leave it scenarios.  Under Section 2-207(1) a ‘take it or leave it’ acceptance results in no acceptance.  Under Section 2-207(2), if the original offer was a ‘take it or leave it offer’ no new terms will be considered.  The reality is that these situations rarely occur in orderly communications such as those hypothesized above.  It happens under time and business pressures, with many transactions ongoing.  Sometimes, forms don’t get read, and if they are, often are not understood.  So, there is no formal contract and you may have writings going back and forth with contradictory terms.
            Yet, the deal goes forward.  Why?  Everybody wants to make money and they adopt the ‘nothing will go wrong’ approach, and of course, sometimes the deal goes south.  The beautiful wood cabinets called for in communications were not up to the buyer’s expectations. There is no finalized contract.  Negotiations fail, and litigation ensues.  At this point, Section 2-207(3) takes control of what happens.  That section states as follows:
 Conduct by both  parties which recognizes the existence of a contract is sufficient to establish a contract for sale although the writings of the parties do not otherwise establish a contract. In such case the terms of the particular contract consist of those terms on which the writings of the parties agree, together with any supplementary terms incorporated under any other provisions of this Act.
The net effect is that the written portion of the contract will consist of whatever written terms are agreed upon between the parties, date and quantity for example.  Contradictory terms will be eliminated and the agreed written provisions will be supplemented by the UCC. 
The application of Section 2-207(3) can have an enormous impact on a case.  For example, Seller may have had some very specific warranty provisions that are part of all of his deals.  If Buyer has presented a contradictory term—very common in a purchase order, you have the classic situation.  If Seller’s warranty has been eliminated because it is contradictory to Buyer’s purchase order, it is highly likely that the warranties supplied by the Code will be more favorable to the Buyer than the ones contained in the documents Seller prepared.

Thursday, December 10, 2015

Section 2-201(2): Reply or Cry


Once it has been determined that Article 2 governs, the next series of questions concerns the parties’ agreement, and possible contract resulting from that agreement:
What are the terms of the agreement between the parties?
How does the UCC impact the parties’ agreement?
How do supplemental general principles of law impact the parties’ agreement?
This basic analysis is called for by the definitions of contract and agreement, both of which were discussed extensively in earlier posts. By way of quick review, contract is defined under Section 1-201(b)(12) as ‘the total legal obligation that results from the parties agreement as determined by the Uniform Commercial Code as supplemented by any other applicable laws.’  It is quickly apparent that in order to know what the contract is between the parties, it is necessary to determine the contents of the parties’ agreement, for the contract is the legal result of their agreement.
‘Agreement’ is defined as the ‘bargain of the parties in fact, as found in their language or inferred from other circumstances, including course of performance, course of dealing, or usage of trade as provided in Section 1-303.’ The importance of course of performance, course of dealing and usage of trade in this analysis is critical, and has been discussed several times in earlier posts.  The essence of their importance lies in the fact that each of these components can supply terms to a contract that may never have been discussed or negotiated.
Once all of the terms are understood, the second element of the definition of contract kicks in: What is the impact of the Uniform  Commercial Code on the parties’ agreement?  The first question is whether the proposed transaction is within the purview of the Uniform Commercial Code. This is the scope question discussed in the last post. The second question which must be asked in this context is: Is the contract enforceable?  That analysis begins with the Article 2 Statute of Frauds contained in Section 2-201.  The basic rule is stated in Section 2-201(1):
Except as otherwise provided in this section a contract for the sale of goods for the price of $500 or more is not enforceable by way of action or defense unless there is some writing sufficient to indicate that a contract for sale has been made between the parties and signed by the party against whom enforcement is sought or by his authorized agent or broker. A writing is not insufficient because it omits or incorrectly states a term agreed upon but the contract is not enforceable under this paragraph beyond the quantity of goods shown in such writing.
Section 2-201(1) is clear and very straightforward.  If the contract has a value of $500 or more, there must be a writing which sufficiently indicates such a contract, and which is signed by the party ‘against whom enforcement is sought.’  Therefore, a purported seller of goods who seeks to hold a particular person liable as a buyer, must have a writing signed by the buyer or by his authorized agent or broker.  Similarly, a buyer seeking to hold a person liable as a seller must have a writing signed by the seller.
            The basic rule of Section 2-201(1) has several exceptions.  The Reply Doctrine of Section 2-201(2) has particular significance for two primary reasons.  First, the downside for not understanding and following the rule of Section 2-201(2) can be devastating to a business.  Second, most businesses are unaware of Section 2-201(2) and hence are in a state of potential major liability.  Section 2-201(2) states as follows:
Between merchants if within a reasonable time a writing in confirmation of the contract and sufficient against the sender is received and the party receiving it has reason to know its contents, it satisfies the requirements of subsection (1) against such party unless written notice of objection to its contents is given within 10 days after it is received.
The best way to illustrate the impact is by way of a simple hypothetical:
Assume that you are a manufacturer of tables that you sell at the wholesale level to retailers for $1,000.
You receive a call from a potential buyer who wants to buy 1000 tables for a motel chain and, given the large order, offers you $650.00 for the tables.
You advise buyer that you have no interest in selling your tables for $650.00 and unless he is willing to pay the full $1,000 you have no interest in further discussions with him.
Several days later, you receive the following email:
            Dear Seller:
Pursuant to our discussion of December 4, 2015 I confirm our contract and agree to purchase 1000 tables from you for $650.00 per table.  I appreciate your recognition of this large order through your discounted price.
Sincerely,
Buyer
You read the email and think to yourself ‘This guy is crazy’ so you delete the email, not knowing that your transaction falls within Section 2-201(2).          
Both parties are merchants, so the first prerequisite of Section 2-201(2) is met.  The writing confirms the contract and is ‘sufficient against the sender’—i.e.—signed by the sender—in this case, the alleged buyer.  Hence the second prerequisite is met.  The third requirement will also be met—i.e.—the person receiving it ‘has reason to know of its contents’ since it was sent to his account via email. 
At this point, unless the seller gives written notice of objection to its contents,  within 10 days of receipt, buyer will have been deemed to have satisfied the requirements of the Statute of Frauds.  This may seem to be a harsh result, but the Code is expressing support for a basic business protocol— answer your business communications in a timely manner.  That is reasonable commercial behavior. If you don’t answer your business communications in a timely manner, and one of those communications confirms a nonexistent contract, you are exposed in a major way.    
This does not mean that the buyer will win in a lawsuit for the 1000 tables at $650.00 per table. However it does mean that one of two things will happen—you will either incur the expense of litigation proving your case, or you will settle.  Both of these can be avoided with a simple one sentence reply denying the existence of the contract.